Caravan weights and safety - do you know all about yours?

This section is for any articles of news that you come across that are of interest to other members. Please write a short description and then provide a link to the relevent website of the item. Please be aware that sometimes the website showing the details may be removed. If you later on find the link not working, please advise a Mod so it can be removed.
User avatar
SteveW
Posts: 2343
Joined: Sun Dec 09, 2012 9:03 pm
Location: Glenelg, South Australia
Contact:

Re: Caravan weights and safety - do you know all about yours?

Post by SteveW »

You certainly can PM me, Motherhen. Dot might get jealous because we do the PM thing from time to time! :lol: :lol: :lol:
Steve Williams
http://stevew1945blog.com/

Every absurdity has a champion to defend it.
Oliver Goldsmith. 1728 -1774
User avatar
Motherhen
Posts: 17
Joined: Sat Jan 12, 2013 3:10 pm
Location: Bridgetown WA
Contact:

Re: Caravan weights and safety - do you know all about yours?

Post by Motherhen »

Thanks Steve - PM sent ;)
Motherhen
http://www.australiasomuchtosee.com
Tips on starting out and setting up, how to find free and low cost camps, trip planning, travelogues and more
User avatar
supersparky
Posts: 7235
Joined: Mon Nov 26, 2012 7:00 pm
Location: Home on the beautiful Gold Coast for a while.

Re: Caravan weights and safety - do you know all about yours?

Post by supersparky »

Whether you agree with this or not, it is coming. First it will be caravans and then it will be motorhomes rated to less than 4.5 tonnes, but weighing much more. The powers that be have been issuing fines to truckies for years for being a little (lot) overweight. Did you really think that it would end there???
Cheers
David

David and Terrie with Bandit the travelling companion
2006 Winnebago Alpine
Recently retired and loving it.
User avatar
Motherhen
Posts: 17
Joined: Sat Jan 12, 2013 3:10 pm
Location: Bridgetown WA
Contact:

Re: Caravan weights and safety - do you know all about yours?

Post by Motherhen »

David, they put their limited resources into where there is the highest risk. Caravans are very low in the risk list. They can at any time pull up and obviously unstable or rear heavy rig. A truck accident has the potential to involve a larger number of cars or people when something goes radically wrong.

Those in the area are very lucky to have an educational focused event like this one. A very creditable effort by the organiser.
Motherhen
http://www.australiasomuchtosee.com
Tips on starting out and setting up, how to find free and low cost camps, trip planning, travelogues and more
User avatar
T1 Terry
Posts: 13613
Joined: Fri Nov 23, 2012 3:44 pm
Location: Mannum South Australia by the beautiful Murray River
Contact:

Re: Caravan weights and safety - do you know all about yours?

Post by T1 Terry »

Motherhen wrote:David, they put their limited resources into where there is the highest risk. Caravans are very low in the risk list. They can at any time pull up and obviously unstable or rear heavy rig. A truck accident has the potential to involve a larger number of cars or people when something goes radically wrong.

Those in the area are very lucky to have an educational focused event like this one. A very creditable effort by the organiser.
Not sure truck over weight is as much as safety issue as a road destruction issue. Sure the heavier a vehicle is the harder it is to stop, but using that formula B doubles would be far more dangerous than a single trailer semi, B triples much worse and quads nothing more than death on wheels. The only problem with that theory is there are far fewer accidents causing injury or death where B triples or quads are involved than motorhomes or caravans. The ever increasing number of RV travellers on the road and the associated caravan carnage compared to motorhomes, I doubt if caravans are really in a low risk group and this is what has triggered the authorities to start to act. Let's face it, if caravan accidents made news the way truck accidents do they would need to extend the length of news broadcasts just to fit them all in ;)

T1 Terry
A person may fail many times, they only become a failure when they blame someone else John Burrows
If we have data, let’s look at data. If all we have are opinions, let’s go with mine. – Jim Barksdale, former Netscape CEO
User avatar
BruceS
Site Admin
Posts: 8879
Joined: Thu Nov 22, 2012 7:32 pm
Location: Mannum, SA, 5238

Re: Caravan weights and safety - do you know all about yours?

Post by BruceS »

As Admin on this forum I've always allowed almost everyone to voice their opinion but I think it's time to stop this thread now?
We already have several forums that tend to have posters that like to dictate and push their barrows.
The topic of this thread was instigated on one of those forums and has now gravitated onto this one.
While I don't see it as directly advertising other forums or other types of public media, I reckon it comes close!
After a short break to take a breath can we please return to normal transmission?

As BruceS I have other views which I haven't disclosed here.
If you wish to add to this topic, please head on over to ----------> there!!
*******************
BruceS
Mannum, SA

********************
User avatar
Motherhen
Posts: 17
Joined: Sat Jan 12, 2013 3:10 pm
Location: Bridgetown WA
Contact:

Re: Caravan weights and safety - do you know all about yours?

Post by Motherhen »

Bruce, by all means close discussion on the weights and safety issue if that is how you run your forum. However this topic has nothing to do with with any other forum/s, no links to any forums have been giving, and is being announced across a large range of media.

Wishing you and yours a lovely Christmas
Motherhen
http://www.australiasomuchtosee.com
Tips on starting out and setting up, how to find free and low cost camps, trip planning, travelogues and more
User avatar
Motherhen
Posts: 17
Joined: Sat Jan 12, 2013 3:10 pm
Location: Bridgetown WA
Contact:

Re: Caravan weights and safety - do you know all about yours?

Post by Motherhen »

With a very successful two day event, which was "watched" with interest from Australia wide, Sergeant Shenton has now compiled his report, and the summary of the results hereunder:

Firstly, keep in mind this is just a snap shot in time. Any figures I give should not be taken as scientifically analysed in anyway. Just raw data collected from those that were weighed or spoken to over the two days.

Next, the actual going out and weighing of vans was carried out to try and alter the perception (well founded) that police do not target caravans for compliance. That perception was to be altered by allowing various members of social media forums, Facebook groups, written magazines, radio and so on to witness the activity first hand and report on it. The object being to spread the word as far as possible that the chances of being weighed have now increased. This was then going to drive conversations and discussion across social media to encourage more caravan users to think about their situation and start to make some changes. Hopefully, they themselves would then help and encourage new entrants into the market to consider weights and safety BEFORE buying their van, not after and realising they had stuffed up!

There is so much anecdotal evidence on the internet about all these big overweight vans tracking up and down the highways. I wanted to test that evidence and get some real facts. I also wanted to get an idea of how much your average caravanner knows and understands about ratings and weights

The operation was setup to coincide with a very busy period of traffic passing through the East Gippsland town of Newmerella near Orbost. Caravans were to be brought in at random to be inspected and weighed. Some did come down voluntarily after hearing about it on social media.

What happened?

Of the 80 plus caravans that passed through the site, 71 caravans were weighed. Only 1 motorhome surprisingly.

All were asked several questions

1. Do you actually know what your ratings are?
2. Have you ever weighed your rig?
3. Do you know what you weigh right now?
3. Can you provide an estimate of what you think you weigh right now?
4. Do you know where your compliance plate is?

Only 2 drivers knew all their ratings
Only 3 drivers had ever weighed their rigs
Only 3 drivers knew what they weighed at that moment.
ALL (except the 3 above) underestimated their weights as at that moment.
All knew where the compliance plate was. Two didn’t have one attached.

Caravans were then weighed by my friends from Vic Roads. This was done by way of portable scales, all fully tested and certified.

GTM was measured hitched up.

Caravan was unhitched.

Ball weight was measured and ATM calculated.

These were then compared to plated ratings for the caravan and tow bar.

41 caravans were overweight in 1 or more category.

Most were within 10% of plated ratings.

5 were 20% over their plated ratings.

ATM was the most common issue, followed by actual ball weight and then tow bar capacity.

Highest over rating on ATM was 2880 kg on a plated ATM of 2600 kg.

Most over rating on ball download was 400 kg on max of 280 kg

Most over on Tow bar loading was 400 kg on max of 300 kg

Most ATM offences were in the 1500 kg to 2500 kg size vans. Camper trailers were the worst offenders. Loaded with bikes, kayaks, generators, tool boxes etc. Most of these had maximum ATM around 1650 and were consistently 100 plus kg over. These were also being towed by the smallest cars, many of them sedans that did not have the capacity to tow those weights. These were generally families of 4 or 5 and the car was also loaded up to max.

We did not have the time to weigh tow vehicles. However, those that were obviously an issue were given further advice. Overloaded tow vehicles are not included in the 41 offenders. If they had been I estimate at least another 15 or more offences against GVM and GCM would have been recorded.

Several with tinnies on the roof were weighed and none were significantly over on van weight. GVM/GCM may have been an issue.

Most notable tow vehicle offence was an older model Colorado towing a 5th wheeler. The 5th wheeler went to 3.5 tonne. The rear axle on the Colorado went 2.1 tonne. We did not unhitch. The Colorado also had boxes of tools, fuel and a generator in the back. They were full timers on the road and we had quite along chat.

Where possible, I had a look inside those vans that were overweight. The common issue here was that if you had placed items on the floor, under beds, on chairs and so on, then the van was overweight. If everything fitted into a proper cupboard and was not loose somewhere in the van, they were generally less likely to be overweight. One customer who was 350 kg over weight plead innocence as to how he could possibly be overweight. Then I opened his door and the first item at the door was an old steel 4 burner BBQ. 4 bikes to add to the 2 on the back, tents, swags, inflatable boats and lots of bags of clothes. He estimated he had 350 kg in his van. He had close to 700 kg if Tare was right.

Almost all were very surprised at what they actually weighed. Some just did not believe the scales.

Some of those using WDH believed that they allowed them to load more than ATM into the van because it would be transferred to the car via the hitch.

One person calculated what his payload could be by loading his van to ATM, then adding on what he measured his ball weight as because that came off the ATM when hitched. So ATM 3500, load to 3850 because the 350 kg was going on the tow ball and viola, back down to rated ATM. That was another long chat.

Of most concern was that most drivers had little idea of what they actually weighed. The fact we only had 41 offenders I think was more by luck than any sort of planning by the driver.

A number of those passing through were given some help in re organising their payload distribution to bring them closer to ratings.

All drivers were given a handout produced by Colin Young from the Caravan Council of Australia. This explained each of the ratings and how to weigh the rig at a weighbridge. We tried to keep the information simple to avoid info overload. Just concentrating on the van helped and when I experimented with talking tug weights, eyes would glass over and I lost them, so that was avoided.

The conversations had with drivers, co-drivers and family were far more valuable than the weight data collected. It gave an insight into how the average man thinks and what he understands about weights and safety. All expressed a desire to be compliant.

Most knew where to find the information they needed, but unfortunately complacency was apparent. The social media campaign was paramount in making this operation successful. The responses to these posts was nothing short of amazing. 100,000's of hits on each article released. Of note was that many of those reading the articles on various sites went on to click other tags that led them to caravan specific safety articles. Police media released their article on the morning of the operation. In the next two days, it was viewed over 52,000 times and over 400 comments left, mostly positive. New pictures were uploaded to police media during the two days and these continued to boost hits.

I also did 3 ABC Radio spots, 2 recorded and 1 live from the site. Local media also attended. I have either written or been interviewed by several other big caravan publications, and had calls from TV shows and other interested stakeholders from around the country. So more publicity is still to come. In essence, we have reached many 100,000's of people genuinely interested in being safe. And all we did was talk to around 80 people towing a van and post some pics of it happening.

Checks in addition to caravans

Two tickets were given for inadequate mirrors, one towing a caravan. There were tickets for unregistered, unlicensed and unroadworthy issues too. One failed drug test but no drink drivers from over 1700 tests.

The Sheriff had a massive couple of days executing over 600 warrants and collecting or arranging payments in excess of $200,000. None from caravanners.

Where to from here?

It is apparent that there is a knowledge gap amongst caravan users. This will be addressed with more of the same. More weighing, more social media. Caravanners seem to have a thirst for information and appear very receptive of advice.

We are exploring how we can get this information into the hands of new buyers in particular.

Continued focus on education for a further period of time. This will eventually have to go into enforcement but there are a whole load of issues that would need to be ironed out before that happens.

Vic Roads have signposted a change in direction and are now happy to collaborate in helping to educate caravan users. This is a change and a fair commitment from Vic Roads as obviously a large proportion of their time is taken with the heavy vehicle industry.

Looking at how to get some sort of (compulsory) towing course built into the sale of new caravans. I know some have already tried but the cost seems to be an issue, so that needs to be explored.

That course could lead to maybe a licence endorsement of some sort. However, this is a huge can of worms and has no end of pitfalls and considerations to overcome, but maybe it is time to have a proper look.

Work with manufacturers in relation to Tare weights being correctly plated. This did come up in conversations. Some had looked at the plate, estimated what the payload sort of was and believed they may be close to allowable ATM. I had to agree with some of them that it was fairly obvious the Tare was wrong from day one out of the dealers.

Together with Vic Roads, I am heading to Mallacoota in March for a few days and will be weighing all the ACC members attending the East Gippsland Muster.

My thanks to those who assisted with this publicity.

Sgt Graeme Shenton
Motherhen
http://www.australiasomuchtosee.com
Tips on starting out and setting up, how to find free and low cost camps, trip planning, travelogues and more
BernieQ2
Posts: 7120
Joined: Thu May 07, 2020 7:57 pm

Re: Caravan weights and safety - do you know all about yours?

Post by BernieQ2 »

Question do the rest of the world use these weights or is it Australia only?
Bernie .
User avatar
Motherhen
Posts: 17
Joined: Sat Jan 12, 2013 3:10 pm
Location: Bridgetown WA
Contact:

Re: Caravan weights and safety - do you know all about yours?

Post by Motherhen »

Yes Bernie, other countries have the same sort of weights. In the US tow vehicles may be rated to tow heavier trailers than in Australia, and in Europe caravan construction is different so lighter ball weights are used.

However in Asian countries is will be a different story, but caravanning is rare.
Motherhen
http://www.australiasomuchtosee.com
Tips on starting out and setting up, how to find free and low cost camps, trip planning, travelogues and more
Post Reply