Lithium, Mixing Sinopoly LFP and Winston LFYP Cells??

Discussion about any electrical topic except 240 volts. Solar, converters, inverters, lights, battery chargers, etc
Barboots
Posts: 225
Joined: Sun Oct 23, 2016 5:18 pm

Re: Lithium, Mixing Sinopoly LFP and Winston LFYP Cells??

Post by Barboots »

T1 Terry wrote:... The other thing against this approach is the MPPT controller...
What if it was applied to the solar input of the Dingo/SSR, or other PWM type "reg"?

Cheers,
Steve

Note: I shouldn't slow your progress West by posting more discussion topics! [emoji6]
User avatar
Firegirl54
Posts: 19
Joined: Fri Jul 28, 2017 6:44 pm
Location: South Coast NSW

Re: Lithium, Mixing Sinopoly LFP and Winston LFYP Cells??

Post by Firegirl54 »

Hi Terry, Questions welcome! Sometimes answering them clears one's own thoughts.
As Barboots has shown, the thing is a dc dc converter. There are lots of them on ebay, some better built than others. The one in the pic there has input and output leads the same size, not good if input carries greater current......The one I got, although a bit cheaper, had about 10g input wires, 12 g output, fit for purpose. The heatsink would only be necessary if you pushed it to max 20A output (380 W at 19V). The specs I saw for similar gadgets suggested more cooling needed if ran at max output. I had the heatsink left over from another project so put it in just in case. Turns out was not necessary for the way I have it set up, but gee it is a real talking point when people have a squiz in the front boot. :shock: I did not want the dc dc converter to have a meltdown while driving along! I really don't trust a lot of the ebay stuff! I have set the output of the victron mppt to 20A (at say 14V), which limits the input from dc dc gadget to only around 16A (at 19V) or so, allowing for only 90% efficiency in the mppt (it is probably better). Again, allowing 90% for the dc dc conversion the input from the car at around 13v is about 25A. I have a 30A circuit breaker in the car wiring and it does not trip. The BMV in the van shows 20A going into the lithiums. The car wiring (only 8b&s as suuplied by toyota) does get just warm after 30 mins. The dc dc converter did not even get warm. Can't give you exact amperages, the above are just my calculations, but so far it seems to do the job. I turn off the solar if we need to use the dc dc, which is rarely. If the solar is left on in the sun, then you still only get your 20A to the lithiums, and if in the shade there seems to be some back flow...no blocking diodes in the panels. Would I do it this way from scratch...no way. When we first set up the lithiums we towed with a Hyundai Terracan, consistent 14 to 14.1 V from the alternator, and with the losses in the wiring charged at about 10A into the lithiums when they were about 50% down, so just let it do its thing if needed. The BMS would protect from overcharge if we drove for 5 hours straight and forgot about things, but again, rarely used. The new Toyota Fortuner drops its voltage down to 13.9 or less and the wiring is so so, so only 2 or 3 A was reaching the lithiums....not worth bothering about. So if we wanted lots of good coffee in miserable weather the additiion of the dc dc gadget was a few dollars well spent. Besides, I wanted to see if it worked. ;)
Barboots - I got the idea for this from some Morningstar tech notes. These suggested that this was a goer for their mppt controllers but not for their pmw ones. They did not explain why, however, or indeed if it would damage the devices....
Terry - Battery charger was in the van when we bought it. Turns out it is almost ideal for our use. Seems to still be made in Hong Kong but not available here. It has a power supply setting adjustable to 13.2, 13.5 or 13.8 volts. The same switch allows you to set the float voltage for any of the charge algorithms. If on a powered site and battery is under about 70% we use the 13.2 setting and very little goes in or out of the battery. If I do need to charge from 240 V (only for capacity testing or to check balanc e at top) I use the gel charge setting, 14.2 bulk and absorb (which never lasts more than 30 mins, sometimes only a min or so...don't know how or why and the basic manual is no help. It then drops to my 13.2 "float" whi h really just turns the charger off). Does bring the cells up to 3.55 V where the balance shunts start to work.
Current has already dropped below 2A at this time. As soon as a cell starts shunting, the voltage across that cell drops about 30mV. I have always manually monitored thhis, holding the meter on shunting cells and watching the voltage skip up and down between 3.52 and 3.55.
The max the shunts can move is 700 mA.
The shunts are part of the "Housepower" BMS made by Dimitri from Cleanpower Auto in the States. The company has since been bought out (by Lithionics I think) and the stuff is no longer available.
The only way to turn off the shunting is to remove the resistors from the board. As I understand it this will not affect their sensing functions.
The CB on the solar input is made for dc.
Hmmmm. Hopefully I have answered all the questions. Off to bed now, the grandkids wore me out this afternoon!
Cheers, Leslie
User avatar
Firegirl54
Posts: 19
Joined: Fri Jul 28, 2017 6:44 pm
Location: South Coast NSW

Re: Lithium, Mixing Sinopoly LFP and Winston LFYP Cells??

Post by Firegirl54 »

Hi again,
Had a quick look back on my Ebay stuff. Apologies Steve, the pic you posted is indeed the same pic as the one I got, same price too ( memory getting a bit unreliable ...) but when it arrived I was most pleased to see that it did have nice fat input wires! They do use generic pics a lot.
Leslie
User avatar
Firegirl54
Posts: 19
Joined: Fri Jul 28, 2017 6:44 pm
Location: South Coast NSW

Re: Lithium, Mixing Sinopoly LFP and Winston LFYP Cells??

Post by Firegirl54 »

Just a quick update in case anyone is interested:

Battery pack is now complete, with 4 100Ah (tall version) winstons added to the 4 100Ah sinopolys, as fours pairs of one each.
P_20170824_164846a.jpg
All seems to work fine.

Charged each cell pair to 3.65V till less than 0.5 A. Then assembled in final form (above), and charged/absorbed at 13.8V for a couple of hours. Current down to 0.2A, cell pairs within a few mV. Discharge at 70A (radiant heater through inverter) yielded 186Ah until LVC at 11.6V. About 100mV between high and low cell. Happy with that.
Further to my answers to Terry's questions (two posts up), was able to use a clampmeter to check current to and from the dc-dc converter feeding the victron mppt. With mppt output set at 20 amps (13.9V), there was 16 amps coming from the dc-dc converter (19.1V), and 24 amps going in (12.1V)...pretty much as I had calculated. Seems the dc-dc converter is around 94% efficient in this setup, the mppt only 89%. But anyway, it works for us if we need it!

Have rejigged our BMS to use the junsi instead of the cell boards to pull the plug if any cell goes over 3.65 or below 2.6. Pack level high and low cut offs, auto resetting as above, but managed by JLD 5740 programable voltmeter. Note that these cut offs are only for protection if something goes wrong. The only times they have ever been used have been in testing..But its nice to know they are there! The Victron mppt manages the solar and car sources, and the 15 amp battery charger/powersupply handles 240 input.
P_20170824_164846a.jpg
The battery changeover switch is there as an emergency bypass of the BMS system...can directly connect charge or loads or both if needed.

Will repurpose the original BMS as a top balancer if ever needed.

All has now been reinstalled in the van, recharged, then discharged again to 50% and disconnected until our next trip away.

Cheers, Leslie
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
Barboots
Posts: 225
Joined: Sun Oct 23, 2016 5:18 pm

Re: Lithium, Mixing Sinopoly LFP and Winston LFYP Cells??

Post by Barboots »

I'm going to have a play with one of those eBay DC-DC converters on my set-up... I'll report my observations when it's here and installed.

Seeing there were some figures on direct alternator charging entering the discussion, I can offer an example of what I measured.

- Fresh pack of Winston 400Ah, with 320Ah removed.
- 3B&S to rear of car.
- 6B&S through van.
- Solar off.
- BMV-700 measuring 13 amps into pack.
- The alternator...








... MY14 Jeep Grand Cherokee at idle. [emoji123][emoji123][emoji123]

Adding in the solar yield produced an almost perfect mathematical sum of what was being input prior to the exercise.

Cheers,
Steve
User avatar
T1 Terry
Posts: 15963
Joined: Fri Nov 23, 2012 3:44 pm
Location: Mannum South Australia by the beautiful Murray River
Has thanked: 50 times
Been thanked: 30 times

Re: Lithium, Mixing Sinopoly LFP and Winston LFYP Cells??

Post by T1 Terry »

Barboots wrote: Mon Aug 28, 2017 8:41 pm I'm going to have a play with one of those eBay DC-DC converters on my set-up... I'll report my observations when it's here and installed.

Seeing there were some figures on direct alternator charging entering the discussion, I can offer an example of what I measured.

- Fresh pack of Winston 400Ah, with 320Ah removed.
- 3B&S to rear of car.
- 6B&S through van.
- Solar off.
- BMV-700 measuring 13 amps into pack.
- The alternator...








... MY14 Jeep Grand Cherokee at idle. [emoji123][emoji123][emoji123]

Adding in the solar yield produced an almost perfect mathematical sum of what was being input prior to the exercise.

Cheers,
Steve
Bet you aren't game to post that over on the Caravaner forum :lol: They would say you didn't know what you were talking about or didn't hold your mouth right or were just telling lies, been there done that and have the knife wounds for my trouble :lol:

T1 Terry
A person may fail many times, they only become a failure when they blame someone else John Burrows
Those who struggle to become a leader, rarely know a clear direction forward for anyone but themselves
Barboots
Posts: 225
Joined: Sun Oct 23, 2016 5:18 pm

Re: Lithium, Mixing Sinopoly LFP and Winston LFYP Cells??

Post by Barboots »

Yeah Terry... I've got no interest in trying to convince anyone of my findings, especially over there.

Thanks for your assistance with my system [emoji106]

Cheers,
Steve
User avatar
T1 Terry
Posts: 15963
Joined: Fri Nov 23, 2012 3:44 pm
Location: Mannum South Australia by the beautiful Murray River
Has thanked: 50 times
Been thanked: 30 times

Re: Lithium, Mixing Sinopoly LFP and Winston LFYP Cells??

Post by T1 Terry »

As far as the DC to DC charger Leslie used, with the output connected to the same side of the SSR as the solar the system would control the output as if it were a solar input but the max current from the DC to DC would be limited to around the 20 amps, but certainly a cheap 20 amp DC to DC charger. At that price you could run multiple units and switch them on as required so the alternator would become a high output emergency generator as long as it wasn't run too long that it overheated the alternator.

T1 Terry
A person may fail many times, they only become a failure when they blame someone else John Burrows
Those who struggle to become a leader, rarely know a clear direction forward for anyone but themselves
Barboots
Posts: 225
Joined: Sun Oct 23, 2016 5:18 pm

Re: Lithium, Mixing Sinopoly LFP and Winston LFYP Cells??

Post by Barboots »

That's the exact plan Terry. I'm going to check the supplier's product, and if OK order another two. Each switchable on demand for scalable output and redundancy. The Cheap has a hefty alternator output so should be up for it, though I'll be monitoring heat closely.

Cheers,
Steve
User avatar
Firegirl54
Posts: 19
Joined: Fri Jul 28, 2017 6:44 pm
Location: South Coast NSW

Re: Lithium, Mixing Sinopoly LFP and Winston LFYP Cells??

Post by Firegirl54 »

Not sure if this is relevant for the way you plan to use the dc-dc, but worth noting that these things do NOT limit their output current ...a 20 amp unit can only survive a 20 amp output, but it will try to put out everything that the circuit allows, and if more than 20 amps can flow it will either cook itself (worst case) or temporarily shut down ( supposed to have overload/short circuit protection ...hmmm). Ours works because the victron controller is doing the current limiting. Also, if you run two in parallel there is no guarantee that they will share the load equally. We previously had two 10amp units (bought at differnt times, so not identical) in parallel, and one decided not to work after only a few uses) An electrical engineer friend suggested the above explanation, even before it happened!!!!

Return to “Low Voltage Electrical”